Monthly Archive for September, 2007

Monitor verification to be included in 3.4/4.5

Serendipity Blackmagic and Megarip have always included a monitor calibration app to ensure colour accurate softproofing. The one step that was missing was verification of the state of the monitor calibration. Currently in development is a new app called Calcheck which addresses this issue. The concept is very simple. Users use the workbench to create a Calcheck chart from either an icc profile or by manually entering Lab values for patches that describe the process they are trying to proof. Generally one would pick a profile for their printing press and then the Calcheck generator would create a patch set which uniformly covers the target gamut. Below is a screen shot of the workbench app showing some patches I generated for ISO 12647-7. click on image for a larger version As you can see from the image above, each patch can have its own Δe tolerance which is used to decide whether a particular patch passes or fails. Patches can also be labeled as cyan, magenta, yellow, black or paper so that they can be identified as such in any generated report. By default, the generator sets the cyan, magenta, yellow, black and paper Δe tolerances to 3.0 and all other patches to 6.0. The maximum allowed average is automatically set to 3.0 and the maximum Δe is set to 6.0. You can even pick which Δe formula is used for determine tolerances. Currently supported formulas are Δe, CIE 94 and CIE 2000. Once the monitor has been calibrated, this chart can be use to check the calibration. I recently chose 3 monitors that we have here at our Sydney office and proceeded to check how well they proof the ISO 12647-7 printing process. ISO 12647-7 is a printing colourspace which makes it quite hard for monitors to achieve as there are some areas which are outside a monitor’s gamut. The 3 monitors chosen were, in alphabetical order, an Apple 30 inch display, an EIZO ColorEdge CG241W and a Sony SDM X73. The Sony is not really meant for proofing as it is just a simple 17 inch desktop display, however it was included so comparisons can be properly made. Results for ISO 12647-7

Monitor Δe C Δe M Δe Y Δe K Δe Paper Δe Max Δe Avg Std dev Pass
Apple 30 inch 23.28 3.31 4.92 1.02 0.52 23.28 4.52 5.31 No
EIZO ColorEdge CG241W 2.19 3.05 2.27 1.30 1.17 3.10 1.60 0.79 Yes
Sony SDM X73 29.76 10.09 10.26 0.89 0.70 29.76 6.76 6.46 No

Below are screenshots of the 3 monitors in the Calcheck app after having checked the monitor against the ISO 12647-7 patch set. Image below is the Calcheck results for the Apple 30 inch display. Calcheck for Apple 30 inch and ISO 12647-7 Image below is the Calcheck results for the EIZO ColorEdge CG241W Calchek for EIZO ColorEdge CG241W and ISO 12647-7 Image below is the Calcheck results for the Sony SDM X73 17 inch LCD. Calcheck for Sony SDM X73 and ISO12647-7 As I mentioned earlier, ISO 12647-7 is quite touch to reproduce so for the sake of completeness I decided to generate some patches for the ISO newsprint standard and test the Apple and EIZO displays. Newsprint has a much smaller gamut so it should be easier to pass a Calcheck. Results for ISO newsprint

Monitor Δe C Δe M Δe Y Δe K Δe Paper Δe Max Δe Avg Std dev Pass
Apple 30 inch 3.46 1.58 3.55 0.88 0.37 3.73 1.71 0.98 Yes
EIZO ColorEdge CG241W 0.76 3.20 0.85 1.08 0.61 3.20 1.27 0.78 Yes

Below are screenshots of the 2 monitors in the Calcheck app after having checked the monitor against the ISO newsprint patch set. Image below is the Calcheck results for the Apple 30 inch display. Calcheck for Apple 30 Inch and ISO newsprint Image below is the Calcheck results for the EIZO ColorEdge CG241W Calcheck and EIZO Coloredge CG241W and ISO newsprint These tests are in no way conclusive as we only tested one of each monitor which is not a statistically significant sample. Once the feature is released we will be able to collect more data and provide more accurate results. The Calcheck feature will be included in version 3.5 of Serendipity Blackmagic and version 4.5 of Serendipity Megarip. Expect them to be available sometime towards the end of October 2007. Note: clicking on any of the images in this post will provide you with a higher resolution version of that image.